Victory Road  

Go Back   Victory Road > General > General Chat > Debate

Notices

View Poll Results: What are your views on this?
American: Drop both bombs without a public test. 1 20.00%
American: Drop one bomb without a public test, wait for response. 1 20.00%
American: Have a public test and bomb them if they don't surrender. 0 0%
American: Bluff by having a public test, but don't follow through if they don't surrender. 0 0%
American: Don't drop the bombs or perform a public test at all. 1 20.00%
Foreigner: Drop both bombs without a public test. 0 0%
Foreigner: Drop one bomb without a public test, wait for response. 0 0%
Foreigner: Have a public test and bomb them if they don't surrender. 0 0%
Foreigner: Bluff by having a public test, but don't follow through if they don't surrender. 0 0%
Foreigner: Don't drop the bombs or perform a public test at all. 2 40.00%
Voters: 5. You may not vote on this poll

 
 
Search this Thread
  #1  
Old February 13, 2013, 09:06:49 AM
Saigon's Avatar
Saigon Saigon is offline
Servine
 
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: Future Gadget Lab
Posts: 63
Default Atomic Bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki

The question I pose today is whether or not the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were justified. Do you believe that the United States should have conducted a public test of the destructiveness of nuclear weapons, in an attempt to convince the Japanese to surrender? Was the bombing of Nagasaki, which happened three days after Hiroshima, unnecessary?



Arguments for the Bombings
-The Japanese would be unlikely to surrender if the United States didn't drop the bombs, thus resulting in a greater loss of life, resources and infrastructure.
-At the time of the bombings around 80% of Japanese cities were already destroyed.
-American and Allied firebombing of Japanese cities did far more damage than both atomic bombs combined.
-A public test would reveal the potential destructiveness of a single aircraft, thus if Japan refused to surrender, they would begin targeting all individual aircraft (including non-bombers).
-The United States was not certain of the bombs would explode, thus it would be a massive international embarrassment if a public test was conducted and the bomb did not detonate.
-The United States only had two nuclear weapons at the time, a public test would have reduced that stockpile to only one nuclear weapon.
-Germany, Japan and the USSR were also developing nuclear weapons programs during World War II and it is unlikely that they would have given a "public test" first and foremost.
-World War II was a total war and thus civilian targets can be considered viable military targets. This is consistent with us using conventional bombs on Japanese and German cities.
-The second bomb sped up the surrender of Japan, thus saving lives and quickly ending the war.
-The second bomb sped up the surrender of Japan, thus weakening the Soviet Union's position in retaking the Chinese sections of the Trans-Siberian Railway.
-A public test may have terrified the American people and they could oppose the bombings from a purely emotional and irrational perspective.
-If we ended up losing massive American casualties by invading Japan and it was later revealed that it could have been avoided by dropping a bomb or two, the public would be outraged.


Arguments Against the Bombings
-The exact destructiveness of dropping atomic bombs on Japanese cities was not known at the time, as the only test conducted had been in the middle of a desert.
-The bombing of Nagasaki came too soon after the bombing of Hiroshima and the Japanese had not finished assessing the damage of the first bomb.
-Continued firebombing of Japanese cities would have eventually convinced Japan to surrender.
-Dropping the bombs could strain Japanse-American relations after the war.

Last edited by Saigon; February 13, 2013 at 09:39:23 AM.
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -8.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Victory Road ©2006 - 2024, Scott Cat333Pokémon Cheney
Theme by A'bom and Cat333Pokémon