My first pitch-shifted song

[linuxlove]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2zZjdZbUlc

Good? Bad?

[Cat333Pokémon]

Horrid. Pitch shifts suck and are a waste of YouTube space. No offence, but I think they're retarded.

[GreenLiquid]

Wow, that's harsh . I don't have anything against 'good' YTPMVs, but a pitch shift consisting of only "MMMMMMs" is not original and not particularly interesting to watch. Not bad for a first try, though.

[Cat333Pokémon]

That's why I didn't give it a rating. I hate all those stupid <Pop Song>: Chipmunks Edition and <High-Pitched Singer's Song>: <Deep-Voiced Singer> Edition.

[linuxlove]

Originally Posted by GreenLiquid

Wow, that's harsh . I don't have anything against 'good' YTPMVs, but a pitch shift consisting of only "MMMMMMs" is not original and not particularly interesting to watch. Not bad for a first try, though.

Morshu MMM is a fad. And a somewhat old fad at that.

Originally Posted by Cat333Pokémon

Horrid. Pitch shifts suck and are a waste of YouTube space. No offence, but I think they're retarded.

If it's really that bad, then the video is down

[Cat333Pokémon]

Alright. Sorry for sounding like a you-know-what, but when someone asks for critique, my honest opinion is what they get.

[linuxlove]

Originally Posted by Cat333Pokémon

Alright. Sorry for sounding like a you-know-what, but when someone asks for critique, my honest opinion is what they get.

And sometimes it hurts. No offence taken to any statement though.

[Jaredvcxz]

Cat, some reviews are best left unsaid. Ever hear of "Constructive criticism"?

[Ningamer]

I'm personally a big fan of 'Pingas' and 'Mmm' music
I love the 'Through the Pingas and Flames'. I'm quite immature when it comes to stuff like that

[Cat333Pokémon]

Originally Posted by Jaredvcxz

Cat, some reviews are best left unsaid. Ever hear of "Constructive criticism"?

Yes, but there can be a point when you gave too much constructive criticism that you just can't feel sorry anymore. At least that's how it is with me.

Same as all those stupid "8-bit remix" videos that use GXSCC and a downloaded MIDI; I just rate them 1/5 and move on. They require no talent, they sound stupid (at least to me), and almost take credit for painstakingly notating the whole thing.

[Swordfyre]

Me personally, I don't think GXSCC sounds too bad, depending on what song you are "remixing". But Cat is right, it takes almost no talent.

And Jaredvcxz is right

[stumpymcgoat]

The only pitch-shifting I tolerate is lowering the tone of Kylie Minogue to sound like Rick Astley and vice-versa